Make your own free website on


baby mix-up refuse to be nurse

Quelques chiffres sur la substitution d'enfants
Substitution d'enfants à Roubaix,1957
Adoption illegale
Adoption ou rapt d'enfant...?
Perte d'identité au passage des frontières

Enter subhead content here

March 22, 2005

Baby Mix-Up

Check out this story.

Donna Johnson was in North Suburban Medical Center after having a baby. The day after the birth, a nurse brought her the baby to nurse. She thought it was odd that the baby wouldn’t nurse, as she had successfully nursed it the day before. She took off the baby’s cap and realized it was not her baby. She freaked out, the nurse who brought the baby freaked out, and then they brought her the right baby. Since the incident she has remained unsure whether or not the baby was really hers, even though DNA testing was done to confirm that it was.

What is Johnson doing now? Why she’s suing, of course. Note that the wrong baby never actually nursed, so there was never any chance of a disease being passed around. Many people would just let it go. Mistakes in the medical world happen all the time, no matter how many policies are in place to prevent them. Why sue if nothing actually came of the mistake? However her lawsuit claims that she suffered post-traumatic stress disorder and is now “obsessed by the possibility that she may lose her baby.” The suit also claims loss of earnings, because she has not been able to return to work, and loss of consortium, because her husband has been “deprived of marital intimacy with his wife”– probably because his wife is acting kind of crazy.

The article also says that she and her husband had been trying to conceive for 10 years. I know from experience that under those circumstances women often get pretty upset and obsessive over conceiving, and sometimes those feelings don’t go away after the baby is born. Something tells me she may very well have had many of the same problems if this incident had not happened. Also, many women who plan to return to work after birth never actually do, especially if it is their first baby. As for the loss of consortium claim - uh, welcome to parenthood, people.

Of course the hospital will probably settle. Given that they already have identification bands that must be checked every time the baby is moved, I doubt that they will be able to really change their policies much to ensure that it never happens again. If you ask me, this is a great reason to house newborns and their mothers in the same hospital room.

Posted by illuminaria at March 22, 2005 12:16 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:


Listed below are links to weblogs that reference

Enter supporting content here